The reproducibility project results have just been published in science, a massive, collaborative, open science attempt to replicate 100 psychology experiments published in leading psychology journals. Psychology was launched in 2011 by the center for open science, a us nonprofit organisation, in the wake of a number of fraud scandals in psychology, such as that involving diederik stapel, who admitted in 2011 to faking more than 50 papers. Pdf reproducibility is a defining feature of science, but the extent to which it characterizes current research is unknown. For example, if your instructor says, please put aside your books, take out a clean sheet of paper, and. But as this workshop attests, even though i will talk about my home fields of psychology and neuroscience, its not just these fields. The reproducibility of psychological science recently, there has been growing concern as psychological research fails to replicate. The researchers attempted to replicate the conditions of the original experiments as closely as possible. Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science kops. Reproducibility association for psychological science. Reproducibility data on display in line with our fields goals of improving openness, methodological rigor, and reproducibility of science, graphical descriptives gds the visualization of research data can be used in the research process and eventually be developed into a. Keywords methodology, replication, reproducibility, psychological science, open. Robust science depends on understanding the science of humans. Finally, ill wrap up with some thoughts about the real progress were making, largely due to changes in technology and beahvior.
Reproducibility can also be applied under changed conditions of measurement for the same measurandto check that the results are not an artefact of the measurement procedures. Psychological science publishes cuttingedge empirical research of broad interest and theoretical significance across the field of psychology. A 2012 special edition of the journal perspectives on psychological science also. Psychological science was hit hard by that problem. Psychological science,journal of personality and social psychology,andjournal of experimental psychology. A new analysis published in science suggests the field of psychology might not have the reproducibility problem discovered in a 2015 study. Reproducibility project 1 estimating the reproducibility of psychological science group author. Passionate, provocative, and persuasive, chambers book. The reproducibility of psychological science mind hacks. Nusbaum and dee posey is licensed under a creative commons attributionsharealike 4. In november 2011, the reproducibility project began, with the goal of obtaining an initial estimate of the reproducibility of psychological science 5. Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science.
More than half of psychology papers are not reproducible. A 2012 special edition of the journal perspectives on psychological science also focused on issues ranging from publication bias to nullaversion that contribute to the replication crises in psychology. Comment on estimating the reproducibility of psychological science. Psychology reproducibility crisis overstated, new report. Reproducibility project 2 estimating the reproducibility. Science paper shows low replicability of psychology studies. In hindsight, the researcher called his study design silly. The study seriously underestimated the reproducibility of psychological science, it concludes. We conducted replications of 100 experimental and correlational studies published in three psychology journals using highpowered designs. Psychological science under scrutiny wiley online books. Johnson ve1, payne rd1, wang t1, asher a1, mandal s1.
We conducted replications of 100 experimental and correlational studies published in three psychology journals using highpowered. Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science science. To give you an idea of the extent of nonreplicability of psychology findings, below are data reported in 2015 by the open science collaboration project, led by university of virginia psychologist brian. Pdf estimating the reproducibility of psychological science etienne p lebel academia. The reproducibility project is an open, largescale, collaborative effort to systematically examine the rate and predictors of reproducibility in psychological science.
Aps covers the results of the reproducibility project. Osf estimating the reproducibility of psychological science. Investigators from a large consortium of scientists recently performed a multiyear study in which they replicated 100 psychology experiments. In 2015, the first open empirical study of reproducibility in psychology was published, called the reproducibility project. So far, 72 volunteer researchers from 41 institutions have organized to openly and transparently replicate studies published in three prominent psychological journals in 2008.
Daniel gilbert, gary king, stephen pettigrew, and timothy wilson. The implications of estimating the reproducibility of. In psychology and other social sciences, many studies fail the reproducibility test. The results are sure to be widely debated the biggest result being that many published results were not replicated.
This project was led by the center for open science and its cofounder, brian nosek, who started the project in november 2011. No, science s reproducibility problem is not limited to psychology washington post, aug. Winner of the 2018 british psychological society book award, best academic monograph in the 7 deadly sins of psychology, chambers demonstrates that many psychologists, driven by the imperative to publish in prestigious journals, produce studies with weak data, faulty methodologies, and questionable conclusions. Following a structured protocol, we conducted 100 replications of studies. But the authors of last years replication study have hit back themselves in science, calling todays critical paper a very optimistic assessment that is limited by statistical misconceptions and by causal inferences from. The replication crisis is, as of 2020, an ongoing methodological crisis in which it has been. Reproducibility is a concern throughout science, he says.
Psychological science, the journal of personality and social psychology, and the journal of experimental psychology. Shots health news many social sciences experiments couldnt be reproduced in a new study. Reproducibility of experimental research is essential to the. Psychological science under scrutiny explores a range of contemporary challenges to the assumptions and methodologies of psychology, in order to encourage debate and ground the discipline in solid science discusses the pointed challenges posed by critics to the field of psychological research, which have given pause to psychological researchers across a broad spectrum of subfields. It started with a report published last year entitled, estimating the reproducibility of psychological science. We conducted replications of 100 experimental and correlational studies published in three psychology journals using highpowered designs and original materials when available. Pdf estimating the reproducibility of psychological science. Reproducibility is a defining feature of science, but the extent to which it characterizes current research is unknown. Indeed, the data are consistent with the opposite conclusion, namely, that the reproducibility of psychological science is quite high. National science foundation report examines concerns about reliability of scientific research psychological science agenda, july 2015. Many psychology findings not as strong as claimed, study says new york times, aug. It addresses reproducibility across the research lifecycle. A paper from the open science collaboration research articles, 28 august 2015, aac4716 attempting to replicate 100 published studies.
The original study reanalyzed and repeated 100 studies published in three psychology journals. A researcher showed people a picture of the thinker in an effort to study the link between analytical thinking and religious disbelief. Resultswe conducted replications of 100 experimental and correlational studies published in three psychology journals using highpowered designs and original materials when available. Reproducibility is the closeness of the agreement between the results of measurements of the same measurand carried out with same methodology described in the corresponding scientific evidence. We conducted a largescale, collaborative effort to obtain an initial estimate of the reproducibility of psychological science.
In this study, teams of psychologists were asked to attempt to replicate studies that had been published in 2008 in three journals. A paper from the open science collaboration research articles, 28 august 2015, aac4716 attempting to replicate 100 published studies suggests that the reproducibility of psychological science is surprisingly low. Scientific claims should not gain credence because of the status or authority of their originator but by the replicability of their supporting evidence. Reproducibility project 1 estimating the reproducibility of psychological science abstract reproducibility is a defining feature of science, but the extent to which it characterizes science is unknown. In recent years, it has become painfully clear that psychology is facing a reproducibility crisis, in which even famous, longestablished phenomenathe stuff of textbooks and ted talks. For example, if your instructor says, please put aside your books, take out a clean sheet of paper. Reproducibility and open science psychology as a science. We are authors of estimating the reproducibility of psychological science coordinated by the center for open science aua psychology ama last thursday, our article estimating the reproducibility of psychological science was published in science. Reproducibility project 2 estimating the reproducibility of psychological science group author. Psychology was a collaboration of 270 contributing authors to repeat 100 published experimental and correlational psychological studies. We conducted replications of 100 experimental and correlational studies published in three psychology journals using highpowered designs and. Indeed, the evidence is consistent with the opposite conclusion that the reproducibility of psychological science is quite high and, in fact, statistically indistinguishable from 100%. Open science collaboration authors on the rate of reproducibility in psychological science.
Reproducibility of psychology studies debate continues. An open, largescale, collaborative effort to estimate the. We conducted replications of 100 experimental and correlational studies published in three psychology journals using highpowered designs and original. The researchers attempted to replicate the conditions of the original. Psychologys replication crisis is real, many labs 2 says. Comment on estimating the reproducibility of psychological.
Report demonstrates need for improved reproducibility in psychological science. We address reproducibility across the research lifecycle. Spellman hails an analysis of reproducibility in psychology by a champion for change. We conducted replications of 100 experimental and correlational studies. Reproducibility is a defining feature of science, but the extent to. Primary data collection was completed in december 2014, and a summary of the results was published in august 2015 in the journal science.
1130 868 802 383 51 744 827 1451 747 1466 368 963 516 498 1133 1066 1265 800 1523 1061 622 1233 1490 389 763 1326 1331 1026 1409 129 1175 916 565 636 135 257 882